- What does it mean to call Irene Adler “thewoman?” Where do we see Holmes’ ideas of women? Why does he note, “Women are naturally secretive, and they like to do their own secreting?” How does this position relate to other ideas of women as gossips? Why does Holmes know he will get Adler to show him the location of the picture, assuming he will be able to “win” the contest and overcome her intelligence? What stereotypes of women does his position rest upon, i.e. desire to care for the injured? How does Irene Adler feel about Holmes? See her final note for evidence.
- Compare the film version to the short story of “A Scandal in Bohemia.” What similarities and differences can you identify? Which version did you prefer? What does that say about you as a reader and viewer? If you have seen the 2009 film, compare it to both the earlier film and the short story.
- The Jekyll/Hyde dichotomy is used as a common motif in literature and film. How did your reading of the story compare to your expectations of it?
- What lessons are we to take from the tale of Jekyll and Hyde? Try reading the story as a criticism of society more than a criticism of the individual. Is there an alternative to this dual nature? Does the story offer any suggestions for a more positive, rewarding and happy existence?